‘Propaganda Video, Shoddy Journalism…’: UK MP Blackman Slams BBC Documentary on PM Modi

New Delhi: Terming the BBC documentary on Prime Minister Narendra Modi as a “propaganda video” and a “disgraceful piece of shoddy journalism,” British MP Bob Blackman has stated that it ought to by no means have been launched and that it didn`t have a look at the “all-important reality” that India`s Supreme Courtroom investigated the claims towards Narendra Modi in reference to the 2002 riots and located that there’s not a shred of proof to assist them.

In an interview with ANI, Blackman additionally talked in regards to the difficulty “across the assessment of the British Broadcasting Coropration`s (BBC) tax affairs” within the context of Revenue Tax division`s survey at its workplaces in India and stated “that is nothing new and has been happening for fairly someday”.

He stated there have been discussions between the Revenue tax authorities in India and the BBC and the broadcaster has to observe the related guidelines and rules. Blackman a member of ruling Conservative and MP for Harrow East, stated that as Chief Minister of Gujarat in 2002, Narendra Modi had performed his finest to attempt to attraction for calm in the course of the riots.

Blackman accused the BBC documentary of casting aspersions and stated this can be very regrettable as a result of it could appear as if there was some form of agenda of BBC to disrupt UK-India relations. “I feel that`s a terrific disgrace.”Noting that the British authorities regards India as a robust pal, and a robust ally and the 2 international locations have been negotiating a commerce deal, he stated something that disrupts the method is extraordinarily regrettable.

The British MP stated the Indian authorities has performed a outstanding job below PM Modi of remodeling the nation`s financial system and it’s on observe to grow to be the main financial system on the planet. Blackman stated the BBC video on PM Modi was “stuffed with innuendos” and it was produced by an exterior organisation and overseen by the British broadcaster.

“The so-called documentary which is extra of a propaganda video, in case you like in a two-part sequence… (was) disgraceful piece of shoddy journalism with an assault on Narendra Modi, each in his time as Chief Minister of Gujarat after which his time as Prime Minister….(was) utterly stuffed with innuendos,” the British MP stated.

“It ought to by no means have been broadcast by the BBC as a result of the BBC has a worldwide fame. Individuals assume, oh my goodness, this should be true. However, it was produced by an exterior organisation, overseen by the BBC….it (documentary) is way from the reality… it truly didn’t look intimately into the causes for the Gujarat riots 20 years in the past and it actually didn`t have a look at the all necessary incontrovertible fact that the Supreme Courtroom totally investigated all of the claims towards Narendra Modi and located that not a shred of proof to assist them,” he added.

Bob Blackman has been the Conservative Member of Parliament for Harrow East since 2010. He was Higher London Meeting member for Brent and Harrow for 4 years, after ousting the Labour Chief on the GLA in June 2004.

In keeping with his web site, Blackman was additionally a Councillor for the Preston Ward in Brent for twenty-four years, serving as chief of the Brent Conservatives from 1990 to 2010, earlier than stepping down in an effort to stand because the Conservative candidate for Harrow East.

The UK MP stated that as Chief Minister of Gujarat in 2002, Narendra Modi had regarded to extra police assets, not solely inside Gujarat however past and finally had referred to as within the military to assist quell the riots.

“They confirmed a movie of him making appeals for calm and inspiring individuals to to not riot…. (they) put a complete sequence of various montages along with totally different individuals… I don`t know individuals concerned but it surely was clear that they had an axe to grind towards Narendra Modi,” Blackman stated.

The central authorities had final month issued instructions for blocking YouTube movies and Twitter posts sharing hyperlinks to the controversial BBC documentary `India: The Modi Query`.The Ministry of Exterior Affairs had termed it a “propaganda piece”, saying it mirrored a “colonial mindset”.Referring to the tax survey, Blackman stated BBC has to make sure “they’re caught with the foundations and rules”.

“Clearly, it is a survey the place the earnings tax authorities have regarded to assemble the proof to ascertain if the BBC is doing something improper, I’d say fairly brazenly, that is the BBC`s job and working inside India, is to ensure they’re caught with the foundations and rules, and I’m positive will probably be cleared up in a short time, however that`s upto the tax authorities so… (for) BBC to ensure they’re caught up with the foundations that function right here,” he stated.

The British ruling occasion MP stated that some sections have been seeing the motion as an assault on the media which in response to the MP was not an correct evaluation.

“It`s a assessment, it’s a survey….the second there haven`t been solutions of fees or something like that…let the authorities function, let the BBC act as they’ve performed in an open and clear manner, offering entry to all of the information and all the knowledge and let the tax authorities come to their conclusion. I belief that we clear up in a short time as a result of it’s for the advantage of the tax authorities and for the BBC.”

Revenue Tax-related surveys at BBC`s India workplaces began on Tuesday. Sources had stated that the Revenue Tax division performed a survey at BBC`s workplaces in Delhi and Mumbai in view of its “deliberate non-compliance” with the “Switch Pricing Guidelines and its huge diversion of income.” The survey concluded on Thursday.

Requested if the BBC documentary might in a roundabout way be reflective of the view of the British authorities, Blackman dismissed any such suggestion and stated the BBC is just not an arm of the British authorities. He stated the British authorities regards India as a robust pal and a robust ally.

“Let`s be very clear, the BBC is just not an arm of the British authorities. Actually, the BBC is regularly crucial of the British authorities and, truly to be truthful, crucial of all of the British authorities that has been that`s their job, their job is to ask questions, to search for proof. However the important thing right here is you possibly can ask questions however when there may be proof on the contrary and it`s fairly clearly not the case, then you definately shouldn`t be casting aspersions. I feel that’s the distinction right here, which I feel this can be very regrettable as a result of it could appear as if there was some form of agenda of the BBC to disrupt UK-India relations,” stated Bob Blackman to ANI.

Blackman stated he had requested the British authorities about its coverage and was advised that BBC is an impartial organisation they have to do no matter they select to do however it’s not the coverage of the British authorities.

“The British authorities regards India as a robust pal and a robust ally. We signed an settlement a 12 months in the past, now an settlement on safety, defence and different issues and that demonstrates the goodwill between our international locations. We’re two international locations with a shared previous and great future forward of us and we’re in the meanwhile negotiating what could possibly be an unimaginable free commerce deal which might profit India and the UK. So, something that disrupts that’s extraordinarily regrettable, significantly when it`s with our basis,” added Blackman.

He expressed hope that the documentary episode is not going to impression relations between India and UK. Answering a question, he stated one factor he agreed with in “the propaganda video” is the ultimate feedback which stated that Narendra Modi and the BJP authorities will most likely be re-elected subsequent time and the time after.

“In order that they deserve it as a result of the Indian authorities have performed a outstanding job below Narendra Modi of remodeling the financial system in India, main India to grow to be the fifth greatest financial system now on the planet, on observe to grow to be the main financial system on the planet, by the way in which it’s going and probably the most populous nation on the planet. We additionally need to have a good time that India is the most important democracy on the planet the place the federal government may be changed if that`s what the individuals resolve,” stated Blackman.

“From that perspective, it`s crucial that we construct the friendship, we construct the connection between the 2 international locations and we achieve this as a result of clearly India has the G20 function this 12 months.”

Blackman, who has been an MP since Could 2010, stated, India can be welcoming the leaders of the world this 12 months and “it`s necessary that we cement our good relations”.”If we don`t, that will be detrimental to India and likewise to the UK,” he stated. 

Leave a Comment